I have accepted that I am weak when it comes to two things: biscuits and doomscrolling.
With biscuits, the solution turned out to be simple. I don’t buy them. If a packet comes into the house, I will eat too many of them in one sitting and disgrace myself, so the packet doesn’t come into the house. (When I say too many, I don’t mean four. Yikes!)
Social media was the same. I’d pick up my phone to check one thing and come up for air as much as an hour later, none the wiser and with a mildly fried brain. So I treated it exactly like the biscuits.
What helped
Some years ago I read a great book by Jaron Lanier called Ten Arguments for Deleting Your Social Media Accounts Right Now. Lanier isn’t a grumpy outsider. He’s a computer scientist and one of the founders of virtual reality.
I followed his advice for many years. I deleted Instagram. I never signed up to anything else. I kept a Facebook account but didn’t use it, and I reconciled myself to LinkedIn, where I found a sort of peace, having decided it’s a wise and helpful tool.
We have also run the Shining Light Project for nine years without social media.
So what we’re doing now is a bit of an experiment. We’ve started sharing our work there, and the question we’re asking is simple: can we connect more people to it without becoming part of the problem? Can we be a positive part of somebody’s algorithm?
Is stepping back even possible?
I wanted to know whether my biscuit method stands up, so I went looking for evidence.
In 2018, a team of economists recruited nearly three thousand Facebook users and paid a random group of them to deactivate their accounts for four weeks. Those people got back an average of 60 minutes a day. Their well-being improved by a modest but real amount, roughly a quarter to two-fifths of what you’d expect from therapy, and when the experiment ended, they went back to Facebook less than before.
At the University of Bath, 154 people were asked to take one week off social media. After seven days, their well-being, depression and anxiety had all improved compared with the people who carried on as normal.
The algorithm isn’t fate
Last year, researchers publishing in the journal Science gave 1,256 people a browser tool that turned down the most hostile political posts in their feed on X for ten days. Those people ended up feeling warmer towards the other side, by an amount roughly comparable to three years’ worth of change, and they reported feeling less angry and less sad while they scrolled.
In another study, still awaiting peer review, people were paid to unfollow the most partisan accounts they followed. They felt better about the other side for at least six months afterwards, and they liked their feeds more.
What we see is shaped by what we follow and linger on. That’s what I mean by a positive algorithm. It’s a feed you choose on purpose, full of people and causes you love, instead of one chosen for you by whatever makes you crossest.
Some rules that seem wise to me
These are only my views, and I may well be wrong.
Wait until you’re older. Australia became the first country to set a minimum age of 16, in December 2025, and the UK government has said it will follow, with a ban expected in spring 2027. Personally, I’d go further. I wouldn’t allow access until the early twenties, maybe even as ‘late’ as 25.
As a simple heuristic, being a child of the 90s, it would take some seismically rich data to convince me that early youth is better spent without social media (and smartphones beyond the most critical apps, such as maps). Be free, run wild, and don’t film yourself and peers.
Beyond the heuristic, there is scientific logic. The prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain that handles judgement and impulse control, is one of the last to mature, and it keeps developing well into our twenties. Neuroscientists are clear that there’s no magic switch on your 25th birthday, so my number is a ballpark and not a finishing line.
But a large UK study found that heavier social media use predicted lower life satisfaction a year later at particular ages: 11 to 13 for girls, 14 to 15 for boys, and then again at 19 for both. And the US Surgeon General has warned that children and teenagers who spend more than three hours a day on social media face double the risk of symptoms of depression and anxiety (the thought of being on social media for three hours makes me wish to cry).
Don’t have it on your phone. In a study published last year, people blocked the internet on their smartphones for two weeks. Calls and texts still worked, and they could still go online at a computer. Of those who did it, 91 per cent improved in at least one of attention, mental health and wellbeing, and the improvement in attention was comparable to reversing ten years of age-related decline. Only about a quarter of the people who signed up managed to keep the block on, which shows how hard it is and makes me feel a little better about the biscuits.
Have a small window each day (or a few days a week). Sit down, open your computer, catch up with a few pages you love, and stop. For me, that’s my friends, and great causes such as Hope and Aid Direct, Pads4Refugees and a select few others. When researchers at the University of Pennsylvania limited students to ten minutes per platform per day, their loneliness and depression fell within three weeks.
Our experiment
So that’s what we’re trying. If the Shining Light Project turns up in your small window, I hope we’re worth the brief stop by :)
I hope we’re a moment of light in it, and that you close the app feeling a little better about the world than when you opened it.
Thank you for reading. Take care of yourself and others.
Much love,
Benjamin
If you’d like to explore living the most purposeful life, we have a meaningful course called Living With Purpose. You can learn more here. It's seven modules you can do at your own pace, with a notebook and a cup of tea.
If you can afford it, we welcome a donation, which gives you lifetime access to the course. And if money is tight, just contact us, and we’ll give it to you for free, no questions asked.